A credit score lesson?

Discussion in 'Credit Talk' started by dm4x, Oct 15, 2001.

  1. dm4x

    dm4x Active Member

    Okay, I am a little confused here.

    Can anyone explain to me what the difference is between a FICO, a Beacon Score and the credit score you get from say Experian via Credt Expert?
     
  2. MikeB

    MikeB Banned

    To make it brief and to the point, only Equifax offers FICO scores to consumers at this time. FICO scores are what the lender sees in most cases. Other scores that are not FICO scores are just tools and do not represent what the lender sees in most cases.
     
  3. numnuts20

    numnuts20 Well-Known Member

    A little less brief and to the point....

    Beacon score is the FICO score derived from equifax report... the score you get from say Experian via Credt Expert is non-FICO. ( now that consumers can get there "Beacon score" there are many new "NextGen score" for lenders to consider from FICO.

    also.....

    "When you apply for credit your score does not come directly from FICO. Instead each bureau has its own version of the rating system with its own name.


    Equifax is called Beacon

    Trans Union is Empirica

    Experian is Experian/Fair Issac"


    from here:

    <http://pre-approvedcredit.com/sys-tmpl/understandcreport/>
     
  4. dm4x

    dm4x Active Member

    Ok Mike B and Numnuts here is how you have managed to confuse me some more:

    Mike B:
    "only equifax offers FICO scores"

    Numnuts:
    "Beacon score is the FICO score derived from equifax report"
    "score you get from say Experian .. is non-FICO"
    "Equifax is called Beacon"
    "Trans Union is Empirica"
    "Experian is Experian/Fair Issac"
    I presume Fair Issac is short for FICO...no?

    Someone else please help! What the hell is FICO?
    Please define FICO, Beacon Score or any score for that matter!!

    Still confused.
     
  5. mj

    mj Well-Known Member

    dm4x -

    It's confusing. Let me take a stab at it...

    1) Credit Score is an algorithm assigning points to various characteristics on your credit report. Some of the things they look at are
    - # of accounts
    - Date accounts opened
    - % of balance vs. limit
    - Type of account (retail store, bank card, finance company, mortgage, revolving)
    - # inquiries in last 2 years
    - Timeliness of payments
    - Derogatory information (or lack of)

    2) The company that patented scoring is Fair Isaac & Co. - FICO.

    3) All three credit bureaus license this technology and sell the resulting scores - TU = Empirica, EX=Experian FICO, EQ=Beacon.

    4) Creditors also license FICO technology and use it in their own systems (for authorizations, new account scoring, limit management, profitability profiling, risk-based pricing, etc.).

    5) Service bureaus (folks who manage accounts for creditors - i.e. TSYS for Sears and FNANB, or FirstData for NextCard) also license FICO technology and sell the services to their clients

    If you want a whole lot of info on scoring, go to

    http://www.creditscoring.com

    or

    http://www.myfico.com/myfico/CreditCentral/ScoringWorks.asp

    Good luck,
    mj
     
  6. numnuts20

    numnuts20 Well-Known Member

  7. dm4x

    dm4x Active Member

    Thanks MJ, Numnuts20.

    I just learnt a lot today. So a FICO is any credit score regardless of the source or name.

    Gatcha!
     
  8. KristyW

    KristyW Well-Known Member

  9. roni

    roni Well-Known Member


    NOT TRUE... Not all credit scores are FICO scores. FICO produces scores for Experian, EQuifax and TransUnion, but worthknowing.com, creditexpert.com and serval other sites have "scores" that are not FICO. To make matters worse, TransUnion supplies a score with their credit reports now, but it is NOT the FICO Trans Union score.

    Unless you have a lender pull a report, the only access the consumer has to their "FICO CREDIT SCORE" is through myfico.com which bases the number on the information in your Equifax file.
     
  10. MikeB

    MikeB Banned

    I thought I made it simple when I said ONLY Equifax offers a FICO score to consumers which is what most lenders see. I guess that was too simple :)
     
  11. CAmove

    CAmove Active Member

    So if this is the case, I still don't know my fico score. I only know my TU score. Where does the TU score usually stack up against the fico score? Lower or higher?
     
  12. GEORGE

    GEORGE Well-Known Member

    In my case...TRANSUNION was higher...
     
  13. SD

    SD Well-Known Member

    My TU score was 633. Equifax was 614.
     
  14. mj

    mj Well-Known Member

    CAMove-

    You have lots of scores-

    All bureaus use Fico technology, but all 3 will come up with a different #.

    Lenders also use Fico technology, but in different ways - CapitalOne runs a profitability score on you, Bank of America runs a monthly "bankruptcy predictor" score, MBNA runs a profitability predictor score... when Ford pulls your credit report, they use an auto lender scorecard, and when Verizon does it, it's a cell phone provider scorecard.

    Now to really muck it up -- different lenders treat the scores differently. Having an Experian 650 may get
    you a Citibank card, but not an Amex Blue.

    If you apply for a mortgage, the lender will normally run a 3-bureau merged report, and will use the 2 lowest scores.

    So, do you ever see the score your lender sees? Only if you ask the lender to show it to you.

    Not that it matters much - consumers aren't supposed to be able to better their scores (that's why we never saw them until last year - FICO's license banned their disclosure to consumers). Only when FICO was confortable that it was so utterly confusing (and the bureaus could make some $$ on it) did they start allowing disclosure.

    -mj
     
  15. tom65432

    tom65432 Well-Known Member

    My TU is 698. My Experian (through creditexpert) is 666. My worthknowing is 50.
     
  16. supershawn

    supershawn Well-Known Member

    ALSO-

    to add a little more to your lesson, your BEACON score (and the others also have a similar method) can actually be any on of FOUR different scores, depending on who asks for it.

    At any one time, you have FOUR BEACON scores...

    - One for "Auto Finance"
    - One for "Bankcard"
    - One for "Installment"
    - One for "Personal Finance"

    Each one is geared with a 'higher emphasis' on the type of financing you are applying for.

    This is a reason our scores seem to 'jump' around a lot depending on who pulls them- well, one of the reasons anyway.

    Be careful, I think that if anyone was to completely understand the whole process at once, they would 'simultaneously combust'

    Hope this helps!

    Shawn
     
  17. CAmove

    CAmove Active Member

    My head hurts.
     
  18. supershawn

    supershawn Well-Known Member

    Maybe this will help......



    Two trains leave Moscow, one going 50 KPH and the other going 75 KPH. Train one is going West......



    :p


    Now you know why they put us through all that in school, it was to prepare us for our credit reports!

    "New" math isn't that bad, it's "Fico" math I have problems with!


    Shawn
     
  19. breeze

    breeze Well-Known Member

    Where does the random number generator fit in....??

    Oh, wait - I get it!!
     
  20. OtherTerri

    OtherTerri Well-Known Member

    CapitalOne runs a profitability score on you, Bank of America runs a monthly "bankruptcy predictor" score, MBNA runs a profitability predictor score... when Ford pulls your credit report, they use an auto lender scorecard, and when Verizon does it, it's a cell phone provider scorecard.

    Now to really muck it up -- different lenders treat the scores differently. Having an Experian 650 may get
    you a Citibank card, but not an Amex Blue.

    MJ - Can you explain this further????
     

Share This Page