collection question

Discussion in 'Credit Talk' started by mindcrime2, Dec 7, 2001.

  1. mindcrime2

    mindcrime2 Well-Known Member

    Got a collection notice in mail today from North Shore Agency, INC. Original creditor: Columbia House. This is for a membership and several DVD's that I selected sometime in June or July 01. I've never received anything from CH, and e-mailed them a bunch of times, each time got a lame response saying it's on its way. Finally I just gave up. Now I get this. Any suggestions on what I should do?.. type of ltr I should send?
     
  2. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    It's all in your mind.Or is it ?
     
  3. mindcrime2

    mindcrime2 Well-Known Member

    lizardking is this good enough: (don't remeber where i found this ltr, either this board or someone on it ) :

    .....
    I am writing to dispute the validity of the above referenced item pursuant to the FCRA. The FCRA requires you to verify the validity of the item within 30 days. If the validity can not be verified, you are obligated by law to remove the item.

    In the event that you can not verify the item pursuant to the FCRA, and you continue to list the disputed item on my credit report <---(should i have this line in there, i don't know if they've actually touched my credit yet) I will find it necessary to sue you for actual damages and declaratory relief under the FCRA. Because the FCRA provides concurrent jurisdiction in federal and state courts, I shall elect to use the Clark County (NV) Superior Court to bring appropriate action against you.

    Be advised I am not requesting verification that you have my mailing address, I am requesting a validation, that is, competent evidence that I have some contractual obligation to pay you.

    Your failure to satisfy this request within the requirements of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act will be construed as your absolute waiver of any and all claims against me, and your tacit agreement to compensate me for costs and attorneys fees.

    I look forward to an uneventful resolution to this
    matter.
    ............

    any suggestions?
     
  4. LKH

    LKH Well-Known Member

    Mindcrime,

    Do not use that letter. This is the letter you want to use.


    This is a request for debt validation from a creditor or credit bureau. Send as certified mail, return receipt requested.

    «Your Name»
    «Address1»
    «Address2»
    «City», «State» «Zip»

    «Company»
    «Address1»
    «Address2»
    «City», «State» «Zip»

    «Date»

    RE: Account #_________/Original Creditorâ??s Name

    Dear Sir/Madame:

    Thank you for your recent inquiry. This is not a refusal to pay, but a notice that your claim is being disputed. This is a request for validation made pursuant to the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Please complete and return the attached disclosure request form.

    Be advised that I am not requesting a "verification" that you have my mailing address, I am requesting a "validation;" that is, competent evidence that I have some contractual obligation to pay you.

    You should also be aware that sending unsubstantiated demands for payment through the United States Mail System might constitute mail fraud under federal and state law. You may wish to consult with a competent legal advisor before your next communication with me.

    Your failure to satisfy this request within the requirements of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act will be construed as your absolute waiver of any and all claims against me, and your tacit agreement to compensate me for costs and attorney fees.

    Sincerely,

    «Signature»
    «Your Name»


    - - - Include the following on a separate sheet of paper - - -


    CREDITOR DISCLOSURE STATEMENT



    Name and Address of Collector (assignee): _________________________

    Name and Address of Debtor: ____________________________________

    Account Number(s): ____________________________________________

    What are the terms of assignment for this account? You may attach a facsimile of any records relating to such terms.

    Have any insurance claims been made by any creditor or assignee regarding this account? YES/NO

    Has the purported balanced of this account been used in any tax deduction claim? YES/NO

    Please list the particular products or services sold by the collector to the debtor and the dollar amount of each:


    Upon failure or refusal of collector to validate this collection action, collector agrees to waive all claims against the debtor named herein and pay debtor for all costs and attorney fees involved in defending this collection action.

    ________________________________
    Authorized signature for Collector

    __/__/__
    Date

    Please return this completed form and attach all assignment or other transfer agreements that would establish your right to collect this debt. Your claim cannot be considered if any portion of this form is not completed and returned with the required documents. This is a request for validation made pursuant to the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. If you do not respond as required by this law, your claim will not be considered and you may be liable for damages for continued collection efforts.

    ___________________
     
  5. Kittw1

    Kittw1 Well-Known Member

    Oh when I was 18 and did not know what I was getting into. I asked for the 8 or 12 CDs for a penny. Got the CDs, a bill (well several bills), and collection letter. Not on my report and never was.
     
  6. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    How could it be.
    All they have is a name and Address that may or may not be real.and no way to prove they ever sent them.
     
  7. wag

    wag Guest

    Woud you please explain why you think this long letter with all the questions is better than the shorter one suggested earlier?

    What requires them to answer any of those questions?
     
  8. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    Because the first one doesn't cover all the basics.

    Your right to complete validation of a debt granted to you under the FDCPA!
     
  9. wag

    wag Guest

    LBBROWN9
    I am not all that knowledgeable about the law. Maybe you can help me out here since you gave an answer.

    Where does it say in FDCPA that they must answer this question and what is the reply that one should expect?
    Where is the requirement in FDCPA that they disclose this information?
    Where in FDCPA is the requirement that they answer this question?
    Where is the requirement in FDCPA that they answer this questions?
    Why do you believe that a collector would agree to this condition?

    I'd like to know the answers to these questions before I go off and do something I might regret later.
     
  10. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    Do a search on this board for validation and another search on lizzardking.
    If you do that I think you will find more information that way than I could ever hope to give you in a single reply to your post.
     
  11. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    Can anyone else on here give wag more input on this also>
     
  12. wag

    wag Guest

    I already did that. No such answers that I can find.
    If LizardKing has those answers maybe he can provide them or give me a link to where he has provided them so he don't have to do it all over again.

    Thanks for your reply anyway
     
  13. mindcrime2

    mindcrime2 Well-Known Member

    LKH - I've got some questions:

    In the letter you advised me to use, should I use the line ..." This is not a refusal to pay, but a notice that your claim is being disputed."
    [Quite frankly I absolutely refuse to pay because I never got the merchandise]

    Also, this letter does not quote any time frame. The shorter one gave 30 days for them to respond, should I include a line in the longer ltr quoting this time frame? Or is it something thatis just understood?
     
  14. LKH

    LKH Well-Known Member

    Of course this letter needs to be modified for each individuals use. The first letter you posted cited the FCRA. 3rd party collectors are subject to the FDCPA. You can change that line to "This is a notice that your claim is being disputed."

    Add the 30 day time if you want to. They should be aware of the time frame, but some of these morons don't have a clue.
     
  15. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    And if they did they wouldn't RECONIZE it.
     
  16. dtg

    dtg Well-Known Member

    Is it ok to use this letter with debts that are 3k or more? I'm just afraid that this will spark a judgement.
     
  17. wag

    wag Guest

    Sparking a judgment is my fear too and that's why I asked the questions I did. I don't know what's right or what's wrong and I sure don't want to do anything that might spark a lawsuit that might not otherwise have happened. I'm afraid they will think I am some kind of a smartalec coming up with those kinds of questions. That's why I wanted to know if there were any basis in the law for these questions or not.

    If there are, then fine.
     
  18. wag

    wag Guest

    bump
     
  19. tonyastime

    tonyastime Well-Known Member

    mindcrime the letter that lizardking just gave you, is the one that I used remember to put your own flare in it. go for it!!!
     
  20. mindcrime2

    mindcrime2 Well-Known Member

    tony, do you mean the one LKH posted? also, anyone, would that validation ltr work for a 2 yr old paid collection(with modifications of course)? coll. agency: IC Systems
     

Share This Page