CR same acct listed mulitple times?

Discussion in 'Credit Talk' started by fun4u2, Dec 15, 2004.

  1. fun4u2

    fun4u2 Well-Known Member

    on the summary page of my CR it shows good accts open 4 for example

    but the same acct is listed 2 x and is showing open as 2 seperate accts

    example

    XYZ open date 2/04 balance $$$ payment history etc.

    XYZ open date 2/04 balance $0 card reported lost or stolen

    shouldn't the 2nd acct be deleted as it is now closed?
     
  2. pd11604

    pd11604 Well-Known Member

    closed accounts in good standing can remain for 12 years on CR's
     
  3. jam237

    jam237 Well-Known Member

    Re: CR same acct listed mulitple ti

    Some companies will delete a "LOST/STOLEN" account, others will leave the L/S account there as being closed.

    The CRA has unlimited disgression in listing 100% positive tradelines, since the FCRA only places restrictions on the reporting timelines for adverse information.

    If there is an important reason for wanting to get rid of the 'closed' account, you could try to see if the DF would delete the tradeline as a gesture of goodwill, but is the L/S account hurting your report in any way?

    The first rule, if its a positive account don't dispute it... ;-)
     
  4. fun4u2

    fun4u2 Well-Known Member

    Re: CR same acct listed mulitple ti

    Hi Jam :)

    the problem is the acct is NOT showing closed.

    for example

    XYZ credit card
    opened 1/03
    credit limit 1K
    balance history for all the months
    never late
    current balance 250.00
    reported as lost or stolen

    XYZ credit card
    opened 1/03
    credit limit 1K
    balance history
    never late
    current balance 250.00

    the summary page on the CR shows 5 good accts however this one acct is being counted as two as if I have two lines of credit with the same company I believe it is lowering my fico but do not know for sure if this is the reason.


    I have asked the DF to remove the first acct but they said it is accurate and will remain any suggestions?

    thx 4 the help :)
     
  5. christy461

    christy461 Active Member

    Re: CR same acct listed mulitple ti

    Hey, I have the same problem. A paid collection account listed twice- once from the original creditor and once from the collection place. Has been counted against me twice.

    I am attempting to dispute it, but it didn't help before.
     
  6. jam237

    jam237 Well-Known Member

    Re: CR same acct listed mulitple ti

    christy:

    The OC & CA accounts are both valid unless they are otherwise in error.

    You did have an account with the OC, and you did have an account with the CA...

    It could even be worse if the CA would have sued and won, you would have a third listing for the judgement to the CA.

    Unfortunately, removal of any of the accounts is dependant upon their goodwill.
     
  7. jam237

    jam237 Well-Known Member

    Re: CR same acct listed mulitple ti

    fun:

    Not sure if the L/S card would be counted into the FICO or not. I remember seeing that in at least some scoring systems accounts labeled as L/S are removed from the scoring calculations.

    As long as the tradeline is positive, it shouldn't be hurting your score. The account is at 25% utilization, and that may be the only variable factor.
     

Share This Page