How should I deal with this case?

Discussion in 'Credit Talk' started by pesao, Oct 30, 2003.

  1. pesao

    pesao Member

    I filed for BK over 2 years ago and would like to rebuild my credit. There was one debt I did not include in the BK because the debt wasn't mine. It was my roommate's. I co-signed a loan at a furniture store because he needed furniture for his children. Now, I know that cosigning is a big mistake, but at the time I didnt. He was a good friend in need. He was making $135 monthly payments as agreed. When I asked him to move out, he stopped making payments. I received a bill from the Store. The balance due was about $650. The original amount according to them was $3200. I would have never co-signed a $3200 loan. I thought it was something like $1250, the most. He probably went back to the store by himself and added furniture before the delivery date, I'm sure.

    I argued with the CA over the phone, wrote a letter asking for a copy of the contract with my signature last year, but never got a response. I never paid it, I tried searching for this pos but I never found him.

    I would like to know if I should send a Validation letter, or what. I notified the CRA last year and it came back as "confirmed" or whatever.

    Any suggestions? thanks.
     
  2. Buck

    Buck Well-Known Member

    Actually, if you co-signed for the loan, the debt is yours. You are the co-signer, so that puts you on the hook for your friend's debt. That is why you never co-sign for anybody. Ever.

    That being said, I would immediately send a validation letter to the CA. Make them prove you're on the hook for this. You can't go back in time and try to include this in your BK. If they come back with validation (i.e. your signature on the loan application), then you could either:

    A. sue your friend for the money he owes you on this.
    B. Settle for deletion from your CR, and chalk it off as an expensive lesson learned.

    If anybody else has different, or better advice, I'm sure they'll tell you. lbrown59?
     
  3. gib

    gib Well-Known Member

    Read here.

    Gib
     
  4. Buck

    Buck Well-Known Member

    Hmmm...it still seems like he may need to go to court to argue this. In the meantime, I would still send the validation letter. Maybe they won't be able to produce a contract.
     
  5. pesao

    pesao Member

    thanks for your answers,

    I understand that I am responsible for the loan. I just wanted to get some opinions.

    I will send a validation letter first. If they reply, I will try to settle. Does 50% sound like a reasonable offer?

    thanks again.
     
  6. gib

    gib Well-Known Member

    Keep in mind the link I provided deals with Illinois law, but much of it is predicated on U.C.C. so can be applied anywhere.

    Gib
     
  7. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

    1*There was one debt I did not include in the BK because the debt wasn't mine.
    I-signed a loan at a furniture store because he needed furniture for his children.
    2*Now, I know that cosigning is a big mistake,
    3*He was a good friend in need.
    4*I would like to know if I should send a Validation letter, or what. I notified the CRA last year and it came back as "confirmed" or whatever.
    pesao
    ================
    1* If you put your name on the............................. the bill is yours.
    2*Sure was but you made an even bigger one when you did this. I did not include this debt in the BK.
    You missed the train going both directions.
    The first time when it left the station by cosigning and again when it made the return trip by failing to list the debt in the BK.
    3*I hope you don't have any enemies
    4*Follow bucks advice here.
    I would immediately send a validation letter to the CA. Make them prove you're on the hook for this. You can't go back in time and try to include this in your BK. If they come back with validation (i.e. your signature on the loan application), then you could either:

    A. sue your friend for the money he owes you on this.
    B. Settle for deletion from your CR, and chalk it off as an expensive lesson learned.
    BUCK
     
  8. pesao

    pesao Member

    "You missed the train going both directions."
    - The story of my life...


    Now I feel more confortable taking the next step. I didn't want to end up in the "what not to do when cleaning your own credit..." forum.

    thanks.
     
  9. lbrown59

    lbrown59 Well-Known Member

     
  10. Buck

    Buck Well-Known Member

    If you're going to settle, I would start with a figure of 30 percent. They most likely won't take it, but if you wind up around the 50-60 percent mark during your negotiations, you're doing pretty good.
     

Share This Page