Hello, I am so glad I stumbled on this website. I have already doubled my knowledge by just reading; yet, I still have so much more to learn. Here is my situation. Once this situation is under control, I am going to work on my credit...as it is not good. Don't think I could finance a stick of gum. I have been in the Air Force for 10 years and make okay money. But we (my wife and I) have some problems from our past that are holding us back. In 2000, I bought a brand new minivan (after a BK) and had payments that were too high. For the time we bought the van, the payments were fine. But in the military, change is a fact of life, and we didn't take that into account. Soon, we were in over our heads and were forced to let the van go back (voluntarily). We couldn't afford the payments...nor could we afford to pay off the diff between the recovered monies and the balance of the loan. The debt sat there on my credit and we received calls every now and then...but we just couldn't afford a car pymt for a car we weren't driving. Skip to now. An agency (Regional Adjustment Bureau out of Texas) has the debt (CA). They have been hounding us. Examples: calling and yelling at my wife...she hangs up and they call back (5 times one day); calling me at work; threatening to sue, garnish wages, and ruin my military career (which I informed him that I have 10 years in, am an NCO, and he can't hurt me...he backed off that statement once he realized I wasn't some E-3 or E-4). They want $400 a mos...which is way more than we can afford. So we asked (over the phone) for documentation beyond their own form letter. They denied. (Now I have found this site, I am going to send a cert. letter requesting validation.) Before, didn't even know if I was entitled to that. Ordered my CR to see what they say. We called our OC and they said it was charged off, they have no paperwork on the file, and they had no intention of sueing. We told the CA that and they got flustered, and then wanted to know who we talked to (accused us of lying). I don't think it was assigned...it sounds like they bought it. The amount is 12K, and they (in the first conversation with us) dropped to 8K - which I don't have. They even wanted me to apply for a loan to get it. Anyway, that is where we are at. I had already decided to play hard ball until I got some sort of documentation...without knowing I was legally entitled to it. Now I have found this site, I have resolved to stick even harder to my guns. I don't mind paying legally obligated debts...but I didn't borrow money from this place, and the OC has claimed it a bad debt. Why would I pay the 12K to a 3d party. Especially if they bought it for pennies on the dollar. If they have all documentation, I wouldn't mind paying it on a plan that I could reasonbly afford. $400 a mos is in the ballpark. Well, thanks for listening. Any thoughts would be appreciated and welcomed. DH
I'm not experienced enough to help you, but I'm giving you a bump and welcoming you to the board. Have patience, there's great knowledge here and someone will step in and help you. BTW, I do believe that their tactics are illegal - but someone else here can tell you better than I. I'm still wet behind the ears. Shanyl
harrisd needs to see the links that were in my signature. Unfortunately another newbie took offense to them so I removed them.
Thanks for the replies. I've read the board for a couple days straight before I posted. Followed many links gathering more information. It's great that there is a place where people can talk about these types of issues and help each other out. I talked to my boss yesterday and informed him of what is going on so IF they call my work again and ask for me (even after they know it's forbidden) then he will know what's going on. Thanks again, DH
Update: I talked w/ the CA today and this is what I was able to find out. They were assigned. If they cannot get me to settle for 8K, they will turn it back over to the OC. I don't have 8K. Here is what was fishy. The balance is at 12K. My wife made the mistake of telling verbally she wants it validated. When I spoke to them later, they said if they validate it, they won't be able to offer the settlement offer of 8K. If the OC has to pull out files and contracts, they will demand the enitre 12K. I said I want a breakdown from what I think it should be (around 8) and the 12K. He said he was looking right at it. So I said what's the big deal with putting it in writing and faxing it to me. Same thing...if he puts it in writing, they won't settle for less. (Which really doesn't matter because I no more have 8K on hand than I do 12K.) I pulled my CR (which I've never done before today...I know, late comer). There is a lot I don't understand...I'll start a new thread for that. BTW: I'm not one of those fly by night people that will take your help and never be seen again. I plan on being an active member. Either to solicit help, or maybe even advice. Thanks, DH PS - he also said I didn't have the right to validation because I didn't do it 30 days from their first letter to us. I said BS.
Another update: I talked to the CA today and he told me he called my work today to get my work addy. I informed him he had already been notified that I cannot receive calls at work. He said he just asked for the addy and didn't mention my name...so I can't stop him from calling businesses. Well, I came into work today and found out that a US Marshall called today and was asking for me, wanted information on me, and mentioned something about a summons. I know of noone else that is at this level with me. My CR is not good, but noone else is hunting me down or calling my house. So I can only assume that the CA and the US Marshall are one in the same. Fortunately for me, I have already talked to my boss about my situation, so he knew that was probably what it was about. No information was given to the individual on the phone and he left no contact number. Coincidence?
They seem to be going to a lot of trouble to get money from you without providing any validation of either the correct amount of the debt, or their ownership of it. Including various FDCPA violations. Who's to say if you pay them, someone else might try to collect again? Did they say who they bought the debt from?
Yeah, I got some more info out of him today. The debt was assigned to them by Nuvell Finance. So we still owe the money to the OC. When I first posted, they wouldn't even give me that. So I wonder, after 4 years, will the OC sue me, or pass it to another CA first. Or chargeoff and sell it.
Did the "US Marshal" ask about your employment, or income? You might call the US Marshals Service and ask them who had been looking for you? They might be interested. Perhaps enough to pull the phone records. Aside from laws against impersonating a Federal official, there are laws (Graham-Leahy, I think) against obtaining financial information from fiduciaries by "pretexting", pretending to be someone you are not. This covers calls to banks, but may cover calls to employers, since they also have and are responsible for maintaining SSN and other account information such as direct deposit account info, on their employees.
It's not past the SOL. Already looked into that. I think. The SOL is based on where I live or where the debt was incurred? I looked up where I live now. (Being military, my addy changes frequently). He asked the person who answered a barrage of questions about phone numbers and addys while claiming to be a Marshal. Then, she was confused by his "double-talk" so she handed it to her NCOIC. He took the call from there. He said he was looking for me (by name) and wanted some info. The NCOIC told him no and to call the orderly room...which they have no mssgs for me or phone calls re me. Also, my CR is really messed up. It lists some accounts more than once. It shows an acct w/ the OC, then a CA, then another CA. So I have 3 line entries for 1 debt. Is that right? Also, some I don't even recognize. Thanks for your thoughts, DH
Hello and welcome The other thing that might have happened in this case is that someone accidently tacked on the "US" to the marshal. A marshal or sheriff can serve papers. Hope that helps.
Well, first off welcome =) Second, since you are in the military there MAY be different rules for you due to this fact. I work in Child Support, and when we do summons with regards to child support it has to be served in an official and different manner than any other person. Although, this may be only for child support S&C's, I am not sure. You might want to check the military angle for rules and regulations regarding service etc. I am still learning also, but I believe they can use the state with the longest SOL - in that regard, when would the last one be up? But like I said I would try the research on the military to see if that yeilds any information that would help you! I really wish I had more advice and suggestions to offer, but I too am new to this and am learning all I can to try and work with the mess I am in also
Harrisd, before you do anything, please, please read the posts for newbies on validation that lbrown59 referred to... I'm not an expert, but here's my understanding of how important validation is as your first step (after you've read the validation posts...) By sending a validation letter (you'll find samples here for that), you force the CA to prove that you owe the debt and you buy yourself some time. Once you request validation from them, they cannot contact you again until they prove the debt is yours (which in most cases they cannot do). If they don't validate, then you send a cease and desist all communications letter. Once you know your rights and the FDCPA rules, you are not at their mercy any longer. There are wonderful, knowledgeable people here who have helped me out of a jam or two and saved me money and sleepless nights. Listen to their advice and read, read, read the posts here. Best of luck to you...Susanna
Thanks everyone. I have read the validation posts. I am definately not afraid and am sticking to my guns. I don't owe any Child Support or anything like that. I don't of anyone that would be serving me papers. I think "he" was the CA. As far as the military, the military has angles toward an individual...but a civil debt is a civil debt and the military stays out of it, for the most part. I've got 10 years in, not afraid of that. But I talked to the person a little while ago that spoke with this guy. Apparently, he was asking for the marshal post...and if this was an AF base. Basically, it sounds like a non-military person asking about military things trying to sound official, but coming off as stupid. So she can't say for sure he said he was a marshal...so that clears that up. But when I spoke to the CA earlier (before I knew they called - I work swings...so I wasn't at work), he said he called to get the addy, but didn't use my name. They said he in fact used my name. That's how they knew to call me into the office. Luckily, my boss is on my side and wants to me fight tooth and nail. Thanks again, Feeling welcomed, DH
Yes, you were right to tell him he was wrong when he said that. But I have a question. What would you do if you demanded validation and the CA actually provided you with a complete validation of the debt correct to the last penny and did it within 30 days or less? I see lots of people saying that you should always demand validation and I agree with that but I never see any posts telling what to do if the CA does do it right for once.
Re: Re: Newbie Well now. I hate what ifs. What if the CA DID do it right? Type in search "CA provided correct validation" I pulled up threads and none of them were CNetters sobbing about having had correct validations sent to them. With 57K+ topics and not one (that I could find anyways, I'll give you that and will look later on today when the sun is back in the sky) thread dealing with your case of 'what if' having happened, I would say it is safe to assume he does not have to worry about it. Reading how his CA goon squad is handling this matter just solidifies it for me. I find it interesting that you are on here since you are a CA yourself from what I have read. Your question to DH was more appropriate for a new thread, NOT for a newbie looking to sort things out. You should engage the experts with that question, it would make for a lively debate and thread. Or...now that I think about it, there is a good possiblity it would be a dead thread and good for a few laughs.